A recent investigation by the New Jersey Office of the State Comptroller has revealed that state troopers frequently extend preferential treatment to motorists presenting courtesy cards—commonly known as PBA, FOP, or gold cards—or citing personal connections to law enforcement. This leniency persists even in cases involving serious offenses such as speeding or suspected drunk driving.
The Police Accountability Project reviewed body camera footage from 501 traffic stops over a 10-day period in December 2022, during which troopers neither issued tickets nor made arrests. In 27% of these stops, drivers either displayed a courtesy card, mentioned a law enforcement affiliation, or showed a badge, leading to their release without penalty.
Acting State Comptroller Kevin D. Walsh expressed concern over this practice, stating, “Courtesy cards are an open secret in New Jersey… They work even when honoring the courtesy card results in more dangerous roadways, and it’s all because of who you know.” He emphasized the brazenness of drivers who seemed confident they would face no consequences, even after committing hazardous driving offenses.
The investigation also highlighted a racial disparity: of the 87 courtesy cards observed, 69 were held by white drivers, while Black, Hispanic, Asian, and other drivers collectively presented 18 cards.
In response to these findings, the comptroller’s office issued 11 recommendations aimed at ensuring fair and impartial enforcement of motor vehicle laws. These include urging the Attorney General to prohibit preferential treatment based on law enforcement connections or possession of courtesy cards and recommending that law enforcement leadership monitor and evaluate any racial or ethnic disparities resulting from such practices.
This report underscores the need for systemic reforms to uphold the integrity of law enforcement and ensure equal treatment for all motorists on New Jersey’s roadways.
Read the Full Report: https://www.nj.gov/comptroller/reports/2024/20241218.shtml
Leave a Reply